Hall Of Fame Candidates Among Active Players

By Sean Lahman
July 9, 1994

The following is my personal opinion on which active players are likely to be inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame To be considered for my list, players had to have been active at the end of the 1993 season and had to have started their careers in 1986 or earlier (minimum of 8 seasons played - HOF requires ten years of service for eligibility). The list is broken into four categories. All names are listed in alphabetical order.

Definitely In (16)
Each of these players will be elected based on their current accomplishments. If they retired today, they would still have a virtual lock on entering. I don't really see any plausible arguments against any of these players. I think their credentials are obvious.

  1. Wade Boggs
  2. George Brett
  3. Roger Clemens
  4. Andre Dawson
  5. Dennis Eckersley
  6. Rich Gossage
  7. Tony Gwynn
  8. Rickey Henderson
  9. Eddie Murray
  10. Cal Ripken
  11. Nolan Ryan
  12. Ryne Sandberg
  13. Lee Smith
  14. Ozzie Smith
  15. Dave Winfield
  16. Robin Yount

 

Good Chance (9)
These players could move up into the higher category in the next few years if they continue to be productive (guys like Dawson & Murray are examples of doing that). In most cases, career totals (milestones) will move them into the "definitely in category". If they retired now, they'd have a fair chance of getting in.

  1. Joe Carter
  2. Kent Hrbek
  3. Tom Henke
  4. Don Mattingly
  5. Paul Molitor
  6. Jack Morris
  7. Tim Raines
  8. Alan Trammell
  9. Lou Whitaker

 

Long Shot Candidates (13)
Most of these players are near the end of their career and have achieved a few things that might make them worthy of consideration. Most likely, they will not be serious candidates unless they continue to be productive into their forties and achieve some significant milestones.

  1. Harold Baines
  2. Brett Butler
  3. Vince Coleman
  4. Lenny Dykstra
  5. John Franco
  6. Dwight Gooden
  7. Charlie Hough
  8. Willie McGee
  9. Tony Pena
  10. Dave Righetti
  11. Steve Sax
  12. Frank Tanana
  13. Willie Wilson

 

Not Yet - Working towards it (12)
These players would not go in if they retired today because their careers would have been too short. They have however established a path that will make them very strong candidates.

  1. Barry Bonds
  2. Cecil Fielder
  3. Jose Canseco
  4. Mark Langston
  5. Barry Larkin
  6. Mark McGwire
  7. Greg Maddux
  8. Rafael Palmeiro
  9. Kirby Puckett
  10. Jose Rijo
  11. Darryl Strawberry
  12. Reuben Sierra

I will revisit this list in a few years to add new names and (perhaps) to remove some.


[ Home ]
[
Search ]
[
Bookstore ]
[
Feedback ]